top of page

Ask AI for a fishing rod, not just fish!

Nov 12
3 min read

Consider this hypothetical scenario: A meeting to sort next year's incoming students into houses and tutor groups.

A spreadsheet was prepared for the meeting with each tutor group as a separate tab with house name and group name in the tab. Students had been added to each tab as a "first pass".




Many will groan, knowing exactly why this makes the task enormously more complex. Many will know how to apply the "once source of truth" rule.

Many may not know and that is ok! Our gift is as educators, after all.


As the meeting progressed, and it became apparent how difficult the "tool" was making the job, someone suggested,

"How about we use AI to help with this task?"

Leaving aside the privacy alarm bells clanging loudly, may I suggest a better pathway forward...

Don't ask AI for a fish, ask AI for a fishing rod

Rather than jumping into AI being the solution, instead consider how you might use AI to help generate the solution.

In the above scenario, a better approach is to provide AI with a faked up version of invented students, tell it what you are trying to do and ask it it create you a "fishing rod" a tool, a sample spreadsheet you can just paste in your real data and you will never need AI for this again (and your students' privacy will be protected). Not using a bulldozer to chase butterflies will save untold amounts of the Earth's resources. It will also save you a huge amount of time.


Consider this different AI use paradigm:

anything that can be done with deterministic programming, should be done that way

By "deterninsitic" I mean old-school; spreadsheet formulas, python, javascript, etc. If you need, use AI as your "fishing rod" maker to help you get there. I consider myself somewhat expert at these tools but I still have much to learn. AI can be a great teacher if you ask it to be.

Warning: stay within your expertise level. If you are not familiar with writing and understanding Google Scripts (for instance) be very careful about using what it provides. Instead, insert a parameter into your prompt, "using only in-build formulas, no scripting". The tsunami you might unwittingly let loose with a malformed script is probably not worth the risk. As you get more skilled, you can progress.


Real world examples.

I do like making things concrete with real examples... (but also brace yourselves for some shameless self-promotion) 😞

  1. Some of my assessment tasks (Such as the Science Extension Exam) are released using googleDrive. For many reasons Google Classroom was not the answer for me. So taking this approach, I now have a robust, reusable tool that allows me to share and un-share multiple documents and sheets with individual students simultaneously. No student information goes anywhere near an AI and it works the same faultless way each time, never inventing phantom students.

  2. Formative class tests (Stage 6) I wanted to gather students' question-by-question scores and I was happy with self-reported data (they are formative tasks after all). Google Forms was too clunky and required editing each week. With AI I was able to learn about web-deployment of a project and now I have a tool that runs itself, placing marks directly into my markbook from a simple, student-personalised web page. From that pattern of marks, I will be better able to help my students develop their bespoke study plans for each Module / Focus Area.


We will continue to use AI for one-off tasks, of course. But we can first ponder, "should I ask for the fish or a rod?"



Comments


If you found this helpful, follow me your preferred social

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

Learning Forge Pty Ltd ABN: 34 666 197 486

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

tel: 02 7229 5606

Learning Forge acknowledges the traditional custodians of the land on which we live and work; the Darug people. We pay our respects to their elders, past, present, and emerging, and acknowledge their ongoing connection to the land, waters, and culture. We recognise that sovereignty was never ceded.

bottom of page